News
LAW POLITICS
On the personnel policy of Tajikistan: who decides?
There is no transparent personnel policy for appointing public servants in Tajikistan, believes Marat Mamadshoev, the editor-in-chief of IWPR in Tajikistan (according to materials from Cabar.Asia). In his opinion, it is especially important to develop clear and verifiable criteria for assessing the effectiveness of public servants. Almost all personnel appointments in recent years in Tajikistan […]
There is no transparent personnel policy for appointing public servants in Tajikistan, believes Marat Mamadshoev, the editor-in-chief of IWPR in Tajikistan (according to materials from Cabar.Asia). In his opinion, it is especially important to develop clear and verifiable criteria for assessing the effectiveness of public servants.
Almost all personnel appointments in recent years in Tajikistan raise many questions. For example, the mysterious resignation of all heads of law enforcement agencies in the Khatlon region, which occurred in mid-January.
As reported then by the president’s press service, “the heads of the mentioned regional, district bodies, and several cities and districts of the Khatlon region demonstrated irresponsibility in the performance of their official duties.” However, to this day, there are no specific explanations of how this irresponsibility manifested itself and how all of them were simultaneously involved in this process of “irresponsibility.”
The composition of the current government was mainly formed in 2020, although several leaders have held their positions for more than 10 years. Personnel reshuffles in the Tajik government have been relatively rare over the past three years. But when they do occur, they almost always leave questions.
In particular, it is unclear why in January 2023, the Minister of Labor, Migration, and Employment of the Population of Tajikistan, Shirin Amonzoda, was dismissed. According to the influential Tajik publication “Asia-Plus,” Shirin Amonzoda was one of the most open officials for dialogue with the public and the press. The president’s press service only stated that Amonzoda was dismissed “in connection with her transition to another job.”
Recent appointments indicate that officials whose main virtue is loyalty have a better chance of retaining their positions. Among the current ministers, there are virtually no media figures. In recent years, no Tajik minister has given an interview to independent Tajik publications. Quarterly conferences have long turned into a formality.
For example, the public was not given clear information about the reason for the mass power outage that affected almost the entire country on March 1, who among the officials was specifically responsible for this situation, and what sanctions were applied to them.
It should be noted that the state agency “Khovar,” whose leaders are more like public servants than journalists, ignored this emergency situation and did not provide any news about it, which also speaks to the quality of the work of Tajik officials.
On March 4, Sorbon Kholmukhammadzoda, Deputy Minister of Energy and Water Resources of Tajikistan, was dismissed. The decree states that Kholmukhammadzoda was relieved of his duties “in connection with his transition to another job.” However, it is unclear whether there is a connection between this resignation and recent events. Especially considering that Sorbon Kholmukhammadzoda was appointed to the position of Deputy Minister of Energy and Water Resources just a year and a half ago and is unlikely to be a key official in this matter.
The tax burden on businesses is very high. For unclear reasons, a number of state enterprises systematically do not pay taxes. Meanwhile, officials once again announce initiatives to write off the tax debts of state enterprises, which have arisen due to incompetent management. Tens of thousands of entrepreneurs closed their businesses last year. A chronic problem has become the foreign trade deficit, which amounted to 2.5 times in 2023. While half of the exports consist of precious metals, the other half consists of aluminum and dried fruits.
There are many problems in the economy, and they have not been resolved for years.
Among the few positive changes, one can mention the growth in the use of internet technologies in some government agencies, particularly in the tax service, which significantly facilitates the work of entrepreneurs. There are objective indicators that indicate the low efficiency of the government apparatus. It is also important to define the criteria for the effectiveness of the government apparatus, as these indicators are currently completely unclear. These criteria should be clear and verifiable.
Tajik internal statistics often raise doubts. For example, the data on relatively high growth rates of the Tajik economy seem implausible, although this can be partially explained by the effect of a low base.
In summary:
There is no clear personnel policy, it is unknown by what criteria candidates for government positions are selected and whether there is a competitive selection;
There is practically no system for training new personnel and no personnel reserve; There is no delegation of authority, no practice of collective decision-making. Most decisions are made by a narrow circle and communicated to subordinates. Initiative is at least not encouraged and often punished. Another negative result of such a policy is that local self-government is not developing;
There is no institution of reputation, officials do not feel personal responsibility. Cases where officials resign due to failures are extremely rare;
There is no constant media coverage of their work. It is very important for society to understand what is happening in the corridors of power and what is (not) being done there.