News ECONOMY

Achievements and Failures of Tajikistan’s Economy in 2023

The main economic trends in Tajikistan in 2023 remained the same as before. All “progresses,” increases, and declines were observed in the few sectors on which the economy of Tajikistan either depends or hopes for. In recent years, several new sources have been added to the main source of income for the country – the […]

Achievements and Failures of Tajikistan’s Economy in 2023 Photo: Internet

The main economic trends in Tajikistan in 2023 remained the same as before. All “progresses,” increases, and declines were observed in the few sectors on which the economy of Tajikistan either depends or hopes for.

In recent years, several new sources have been added to the main source of income for the country – the remittances of Tajik migrants from abroad. However, remittances from migrants still remain the main driver of the country’s economy. Of course, attempts by the authorities to downplay the contribution of migrants to the country’s economy have not gone without results.

At the same time, unlike the remittances of labor migrants, which cannot be directly used to replenish the state budget or pay off public debt, other sources have managed to influence these two areas. So much so that this year the annual plan for revenue to the state budget has already been exceeded, and the country’s external debt has decreased.

Another economic issue that is always on the front pages of the media and discussed by the government is the “construction of the century” in the country, namely the “Rogun Hydropower Plant,” and at the same time the constant shortage of electricity in the country, which has also been hotly debated this year.

Gold instead of migrant remittances

Over the past four years, Tajikistan has observed a positive trade balance, and for the first time in the country’s history, in 2021, the country exported more goods than it imported. This is despite the fact that previously the trade balance was always three to one in favor of imports. This “jump” was achieved through the sale of gold, as the government was forced to sell the country’s gold reserves. As a result, for two years Switzerland remained Tajikistan’s second-largest trading partner, and the volume of gold sales amounted to nearly one billion dollars, or a third of the country’s state budget. The main reason for the government’s sale of gold reserves during these years was the decrease in the flow of remittances from migrants, which was triggered by the coronavirus pandemic and later by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

However, this year the sale of gold reserves, which the authorities officially call “export of precious metals,” has practically ceased. According to the World Bank, the volume of “precious metals” exports in the first half of this year decreased by 350 times compared to the same period last year: 500 thousand dollars versus 175 million dollars. Moreover, in 2022, gold sales were not at their peak. If this figure is compared to the same period in 2020, the difference is more than 800 times. At that time, the country exported gold worth over 400 million dollars.

Despite exports, Tajikistan was able to increase its gold and foreign exchange reserves by 4 tons in 2022. According to the National Bank of Tajikistan, last year the country’s gold and foreign exchange reserves exceeded the adequacy standards of international financial institutions. Additionally, according to the World Bank, the country’s gold and foreign exchange reserves increased by $3.8 billion. The cessation of gold sales this year has likely significantly increased the country’s gold reserves, although official data has not yet been published.

It can be said that this year has been golden for the country in terms of gold extraction and reserves, as in addition to the increase in gold and foreign exchange reserves, 10 new gold deposits were opened in the country, and the price of gold has risen by 20 percent in the last few weeks.

Remittances from migrants instead of gold

The World Bank attributed the cessation of gold exports by Tajikistan to the increase in the flow of foreign currency from several other sources, the main one being, of course, remittances from migrants.

Contrary to the forecasts of most international financial institutions, in 2022 and 2023, instead of a decline in the Russian economy, there was growth, and labor migrants in this country had significant incomes. As a result, remittances from Russia to labor-exporting countries, including Tajikistan, increased significantly.

The Central Bank of Russia, in its statistics for these two years, refrained from mentioning the volume of remittances to Tajikistan, and Tajikistan turned out to be the only country not mentioned in this statistics. Previously, the country always ranked second or third in the list of countries receiving remittances from Russia. The reason why Tajikistan is not mentioned in the Central Bank of Russia’s statistics is unknown, but experts believe that this was done at the request of Tajikistan. In their opinion, the authorities of Tajikistan have always tried to downplay the contribution of remittances from Tajik migrants to the country’s economy.

However, the World Bank revealed this data and announced in the middle of this year that last year labor migrants transferred a record amount of $5.2 billion to Tajikistan, which is equal to 49 percent of Tajikistan’s GDP. Previously, the World Bank had predicted that the volume of remittances from migrants would be around 30 percent of GDP. The statistics for this year have not yet been published, but forecasts suggest that the volume of remittances from migrants will be higher than last year. The main reason for this forecast is the near-total cessation of gold exports that had been carried out over the past 4 years.

Overfulfillment of the budget revenue plan

For the second consecutive year, Tajikistan has exceeded the revenue plan of its budget, which is unprecedented in the country’s history. In just the first half of this year, the country exceeded its budget plan by approximately 1 billion somoni or about 92 million US dollars. It is expected that the plan will also be exceeded in the second half of the year, but for several reasons, it may not reach the level of the first half.

At the same time, the country has provided some tax benefits, including reducing the standard value-added tax (VAT) rate from 18% to 15%.

Experts had predicted that these benefits could negatively affect the execution of the budget revenue plan; however, the reality turned out to be the opposite.

International institutions, including the World Bank, believe that the reason for exceeding the budget plan is primarily due to an increase in the extraction of underground mineral resources and the cancellation of some tax benefits. Additionally, a record growth in remittances to the country has led to increased demand in the domestic market, resulting in higher tax revenues.

New benefits for companies close to the president’s family

The World Bank linked the budget plan’s overachievement to the cancellation of some tax benefits, although the country continued the tradition of providing benefits to “its” companies, meaning companies affiliated with close relatives of President Emomali Rahmon.

For example, the airline “Somon Air,” owned by Hasan Asadullozoda, the brother-in-law of Emomali Rahmon, was exempted from paying certain taxes and customs duties. By government decision and with parliamentary approval, this company was exempted from paying VAT and customs duties when importing aircraft, their engines, as well as fuel and lubricants for the aircraft.

This means that with the exemption from VAT when importing just one aircraft, the budget could lose up to 20 million dollars (the cost of the aircraft used by “Somon Air” ranges from 90 to 160 million dollars).

In addition to “Somon Air,” several other companies owned by members of the president’s family, including “Avesto Group” (owner – Rustam Emomali), “Sifat Pharma” (owner – Parvina Emomali), and several others, have been exempted from paying taxes and customs duties in various areas, including the import of electric vehicles.

Forecast for an increase in external debt

Despite the fact that due to a number of the aforementioned factors, the country’s debt has decreased by approximately 100 million dollars, authorities predict that the external debt will increase by 140 million dollars and reach 4.1 billion dollars next year. The government plans to obtain about 300 million dollars in new loans and repay just over 250 million dollars in old loans.

International financial institutions have repeatedly urged Tajikistan to reconsider its credit policy, as the large state debt remains one of the main risks for the country’s economy in the medium term.

Loans and grants amounting to about 2 billion dollars

At the same time, this year the government managed to negotiate large grants totaling nearly 2 billion dollars. The largest of these will be provided by the Eurasian Development Bank (EADB), the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB), and the Islamic Development Bank (IDB).

The Eurasian Development Bank is expected to allocate 650 million dollars to Tajikistan from 2023 to 2026 for the implementation of priority projects.

The Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, which is a Chinese bank, has shown interest in the construction of the “Rogun Hydropower Plant” and promised a concessional loan of half a billion dollars. Although this loan has been labeled concessional, neither party has disclosed the terms of the loan.

The Islamic Development Bank, like the Eurasian Development Bank, has promised a grant of 450 million dollars for the implementation of priority projects. The total amount of these three major loans and grants reaches 1.6 billion dollars. In addition, the government of Tajikistan has agreed on several more loans and grants.

Interest in the “Rogun Hydropower Plant”

China is not the only country interested in the construction of the Rogun Hydropower Plant. In addition to the half-billion dollar Chinese loan for Tajikistan’s “construction of the century,” the Saudi Development Fund is providing 100 million dollars for the Rogun Hydropower Plant project in the form of “concessional loans.” The terms of this loan have also not been disclosed.

The Eurasian Development Bank will also allocate 130 million dollars for the construction of the Rogun Hydropower Plant. Additionally, the authorities of Tajikistan are negotiating with the World Bank, the European Investment Bank, the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority, the Kuwait Fund for Arab Economic Development, and others to attract new investments for the construction of the Rogun Hydropower Plant.

Remarkably, after the interest of international financial institutions in the project increased, the government of Tajikistan sharply raised the cost of constructing the Rogun Hydropower Plant. In 2008, when the construction of the Rogun Hydropower Plant resumed, it was reported that the cost of the project was 3 billion dollars. In 2016, a new amount was announced: 3.9 billion dollars. In mid-2022, the Ministry of Energy of the country stated that 5 billion dollars were needed to complete the construction of the Rogun Hydropower Plant. Today, the government has increased this amount to 6 billion dollars.

The “blow” of gold on the foreign trade balance

After the “unique success” of the country’s economy, that is, the reduction of the huge gap between imports and exports, this year the foreign trade balance has returned to its previous level. This means that the difference between exports and imports has once again increased almost threefold.

The main reason for the loss of the unprecedented “success” was the cessation of gold sales by the country, and Switzerland has fallen to the second decade in the list of Tajikistan’s trading partners.

At the same time, gold was not the only reason for the restoration of the previous negative balance. Exports of aluminum, cotton fiber, and fruits have also declined this year.

High inflation and low positions in rankings

The inflation rate of the national currency, somoni, this year was 7 percent. This is how much value the national currency has lost.

As before, Tajikistan ranked 146th in the index of economic freedom. The situation in other economic rankings has also not changed. The average income of the country’s population is still less than the average consumer basket, and wage growth has still not caught up with inflation.

Related topics