News CENTRAL ASIA HUMAN RIGHTS

Central Asia – a bastion of “consolidated” authoritarianism

The international organization Freedom House notes in its report that Central Asian countries have further solidified their status as “authoritarian regimes.” The war catalyzes the expansion of authoritarian practices. The prospect of establishing the rule of law in many former Soviet states is bleak. With the exception of Russia and Azerbaijan, the most dire situation […]

Central Asia – a bastion of “consolidated” authoritarianism Photo: Internet

The international organization Freedom House notes in its report that Central Asian countries have further solidified their status as “authoritarian regimes.”

The war catalyzes the expansion of authoritarian practices. The prospect of establishing the rule of law in many former Soviet states is bleak. With the exception of Russia and Azerbaijan, the most dire situation is observed in Central Asia.

The latest part of Freedom House’s annual report “Countries in Transition 2024” shows that all five Central Asian states were classified as “consolidated authoritarian regimes,” which is the lowest category in the study in terms of individual rights and competitive political systems.

The report assessed the state of political freedom in 29 countries that once had communist systems. Only eight countries received the status of “consolidated authoritarian.” According to the Freedom House ranking, Belarus became the eighth state in the authoritarian confederation.

Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uzbekistan saw a decline in rule of law indicators in 2023, which Freedom House determined by examining seven categories of indicators, including press freedom, an independent judiciary, and the electoral process.

“In Uzbekistan, President Shavkat Mirziyoyev’s regime adopted bold constitutional amendments that paved the way for extending his rule until 2040,” the report notes. “Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan, which were previously on the less repressive end of the authoritarian spectrum, now align with the broader Central Asian trend of authoritarian consolidation. The regimes in these two countries have been working to suppress local autonomy and civil society activity.”

Assessments of Tajikistan and Turkmenistan remained unchanged but were the lowest among all surveyed countries – even worse than Russia.

Freedom House expressed concern that “ongoing attempts by Russia to destroy Ukraine,” along with Azerbaijan’s return to Nagorno-Karabakh, are catalyzing the expansion of authoritarian practices. “These and other events in recent years have accelerated the geopolitical restructuring in the region, with countries dividing into two opposing blocs: those committed to a liberal, democratic order and those that vehemently reject it.”

Authoritarian states are strengthening their political frameworks by expanding mutual economic cooperation. In the context of Central Asia, the report mentions Uzbekistan’s plan to spend $500 million to expand its pipeline network to meet the growing Russian imports as a step that could “benefit the economic and political stability of both authoritarian regimes.”

The only hope for the revival of the rule of law in Eurasia, the report states, lies in the fact that democratically inclined Western states will work together to ensure that Russia cannot achieve its strategic goals in Ukraine.

“The future of European democracy and security is now inextricably linked to the fate of Ukraine,” the report says. “EU and NATO member states must not only invest much more – and more effectively – in their collective defense, but also provide Ukraine with the assistance it needs to repel Russia’s offensive and build its own resilient democracy.”

Related topics