News AFGHANISTAN POLITICS

Expert Opinion: How the Friendship Between the Kremlin and the Taliban Will Develop

At the beginning of the week, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation proposed to Vladimir Putin to remove the Taliban from the list of banned organizations in Russia. Experts believe that this will likely be followed by Russia recognizing the Taliban government as legitimate – despite the […]

Expert Opinion: How the Friendship Between the Kremlin and the Taliban Will Develop Photo: Internet

At the beginning of the week, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation proposed to Vladimir Putin to remove the Taliban from the list of banned organizations in Russia.

Experts believe that this will likely be followed by Russia recognizing the Taliban government as legitimate – despite the widespread human rights violations in Afghanistan and the manner in which the Taliban came to power.

How likely is such a development in relations between the Kremlin and the Taliban? And what economic decisions might follow? Does this mean that Russia intends to invest in Afghanistan along with Central Asian countries and China? Current Time posed this question to political scientist and security expert Rustam Burnashev.

– This is not the first time that Russian authorities have mentioned the need to remove the “Taliban” from the list of terrorist organizations. Do you think this will happen this time?

– I think yes, the “Taliban” will be removed from the Russian list of terrorist organizations; all dynamics suggest that such a decision will be made in this case. It is difficult for me to speak about the timing of when this will be done: I do not work within the Russian internal decision-making system. But it seems to me that yes, this decision will be brought to the Supreme Court in the near future, and most likely, it will be adopted.

– Let’s imagine that Russia has already done this. Should we expect that the Taliban government in Afghanistan will also be recognized as legitimate by Russia? Even though no country in the world has officially recognized the Taliban’s authority?

– It is difficult to speak about the likelihood of recognizing the “Taliban” government because there is a certain international consensus regarding the recognition or non-recognition of this government. This consensus implies that the Taliban government must undertake a series of actions, which are practically unfeasible for the Taliban. Therefore, it seems to me that the Kremlin will work with the “Taliban” government de facto, but not de jure.

– What might prevent the Russian authorities from recognizing the Taliban government?

– Simply a certain consensus. Moreover, there is no necessity for such recognition. For example, we see that Uzbekistan, while not recognizing the Taliban government de jure, interacts excellently with them and effectively resolves issues that fall within Uzbekistan’s sphere of interest. The same is done by Kazakhstan, for instance.

Therefore, it seems to me that the Kremlin will not recognize the “Taliban” government in order not to undermine certain ideological positions. However, interaction with the Taliban will increase, and there will be no restrictions or comical situations where the Russian Foreign Minister meets with representatives of an organization that is considered terrorist in this country.

– Yes, it certainly looks comical. You have already touched upon the topic of the Taliban government’s connection with Central Asian countries. How will the decision to exclude the Taliban from the list of terrorist organizations in Russia affect Central Asian countries? Could they also follow Russia’s example? Especially since, as you have already reminded us, the countries in our region have contacts with the Taliban government to some extent?

– Well, only Tajikistan will probably have to follow Russia’s example here, because, if I’m not mistaken, for the other countries the Taliban are not considered a terrorist organization (I have some doubts regarding Kyrgyzstan). Therefore, there is simply no problem here like “we are interacting with terrorists.” Kazakhstan removed the Taliban movement from the terrorist list earlier than Russia and is currently interacting quite actively with the Taliban movement. And, in fact, in this case, it is more likely that Russia is following the example of Central Asian countries, rather than the other way around.

– How will the security situation in the region change after this decision? It turns out that the Taliban will turn from enemies into allies, and the only “real” threat will become the Islamic State’s Khorasan Province?

– They will not become allies, of course. Not every organization, not every country that is not positioned as an enemy is immediately an ally. They will simply be partners, or rather, they already are partners. But in this case, they will be partners with whom it will be possible to work, again, without creating such strange situations. That is, economic interaction with Afghanistan will not have the same boundaries for Russia as it does now.

Accordingly, one can assume that Russia will invest more actively in the economy of this country together with Central Asian countries, perhaps along with Chinese partners. And in this regard, the interaction will simply strengthen.

How this will affect security in the region depends on how we position security. For example, I personally believe that yes, economic development will improve the security situation, because we already have this experience. We have the experience of Uzbekistan’s interaction with Afghanistan, with pre-Taliban Afghanistan, when railways were built, and a system for servicing these railways was created. And the situation in Northern Afghanistan has normalized to some extent because of this. I hope that this is the direction in which the situation in Afghanistan will develop in this case. Yes, of course, there will still be human security problems; they will not go away. And here we will have to work separately, very carefully and very attentively.

– Could there be joint military exercises? Will Russia, for example, deepen military cooperation with the Taliban, selling them weapons, for instance?

– Russia, I believe, is currently not ready to sell weapons to anyone due to the situation in Russia, given that Russia is involved in military actions. Therefore, this option is not considered by me, for example, as likely. And it is unlikely that the Taliban currently needs this weaponry.

Related topics