News
HUMAN RIGHTS TAJIKISTAN
Human rights organizations urged EU countries and Turkey not to return Tajik dissidents to their homeland
International organizations Human Rights Watch and the Norwegian Helsinki Committee have urged the authorities of EU countries and Turkey not to deport Tajik opposition activists to Tajikistan. Several individuals living in Lithuania, Poland, and Turkey and linked to the banned Tajik opposition movement “Group 24” have disappeared or been arrested in recent months, facing threats […]
International organizations Human Rights Watch and the Norwegian Helsinki Committee have urged the authorities of EU countries and Turkey not to deport Tajik opposition activists to Tajikistan.
Several individuals living in Lithuania, Poland, and Turkey and linked to the banned Tajik opposition movement “Group 24” have disappeared or been arrested in recent months, facing threats of extradition to Tajikistan. This was stated on April 16, 2024, by the Norwegian Helsinki Committee and Human Rights Watch.
“Group 24” is a political movement advocating for democratic reforms in Tajikistan, which the Tajik government banned and declared a terrorist organization in October 2014. For the past decade, Tajikistan has sought the extradition of exiled activists to other countries, some of whom have also been killed or forcibly disappeared. The governments of host countries should not deport these individuals to Tajikistan due to the risk of torture and must respect all rights of Tajik asylum seekers to due process, including not subjecting them to arbitrary detention based on unfounded and politically motivated requests from the Tajik government.
“Tajikistan must unconditionally end its decade-long hunt for alleged critics abroad, especially those associated with ‘Group 24’ and other banned groups,” said Syinat Sultanalieva, Central Asia researcher at Human Rights Watch. “The EU and Turkey must protect opposition activists and refrain from returning them to Tajikistan, a country known for transnational repression, where they risk being tortured.”
Human Rights Watch recently published a report on transnational repression – the persecution of critics abroad by repressive governments – which includes several cases of members of “Group 24,” both former and active, who fled the country only to become targets of the Tajik government in their quest for freedom, facing arrest and extradition to Tajikistan on charges of terrorism or activities related to extremism. Exiled activists have also faced enforced disappearances or abuses in the use of Interpol’s “red notices,” which are requests to law enforcement agencies worldwide to locate and provisionally arrest a person as the government seeks their extradition.
On April 5, 2024, Lithuanian security services detained former “Group 24” member Sulaymon Davlatov in Vilnius on charges of allegedly violating Lithuania’s national security. On April 7, a court in Vilnius ordered his pre-trial detention for two months, and on April 9, the Lithuanian Prosecutor General’s Office informed the media that Davlatov “poses a threat to Lithuania’s national security due to his cooperation with members and allies of terrorist organizations, extremist movements, and the promotion of extremism.”
Davlatov has been living in Lithuania since he was granted asylum in 2015. Lithuanian authorities must eliminate any risk that Davlatov could be extradited to Tajikistan and, in accordance with the rights to a fair trial, provide Davlatov and his lawyer with immediate access to any evidence they have to substantiate the charges.
On February 23 and March 10, respectively, two high-ranking members of “Group 24” — Nasimjon Sharifov and Sukhrab Zafar — went missing in Turkey. Both had previously been detained by Turkish police in March 2018 at the request of Tajik authorities and were threatened with extradition, but were ultimately released. Recently, they informed their family and colleagues that they regularly receive threats from Tajik security services. The whereabouts of both men are currently unknown. Friends and colleagues are concerned that they may have been forcibly disappeared by Tajik and Turkish authorities or both and unlawfully removed to Tajikistan.
On March 19, a court in Poland ordered Komron Khudoydodov, the brother of former “Group 24” activist Shabnam Khudoydodova, to voluntarily leave Poland by April 19 or be deported to Tajikistan. This followed the rejection of his asylum application. Khudoydodov moved to Poland in 2018 on a humanitarian visa issued by Polish authorities, as he faced persecution in Tajikistan due to his sister’s peaceful political activities. In 2015, Tajik authorities placed Shabnam Khudoydodova on Interpol’s red notices for alleged extremism.
Tajik authorities are also continuing a criminal investigation against Komron Khudoydodov on charges of extremism. His return to Tajikistan would put him at risk of torture or ill-treatment and would therefore violate the prohibition on refoulement. Poland must make it clear that it will uphold its international legal obligations and exclude the deportation of Khudoydodov to Tajikistan. In addition to Lithuania and Poland, other European Union members, such as Austria, Germany, and Slovakia, have in recent years returned or threatened to return Tajik asylum seekers to Tajikistan, despite credible evidence that they face the risk of torture. Upon arrival in Tajikistan, deportees from EU member states have been imprisoned.
The UN Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment prohibits the expulsion, return (refoulement), or extradition of a person to another state if there are serious grounds for believing that they would face a risk of torture. The European Convention on Human Rights also includes this prohibition as part of the ban on torture and inhuman or degrading treatment. All EU member states and Turkey are parties to both treaties. This principle is also incorporated into the domestic legislation of Lithuania, Poland, and Turkey.
“EU member states and Turkey must adhere to their international obligations regarding human rights, including not returning individuals who face torture and persecution for political activity to their country of origin,” said Sultanalieva. “They must condemn instances of transnational repression and reconsider any agreements on cooperation with states that persecute critics abroad.”